TRANS COMMUNITY: Kind of an apology, not quite a commentary, not quite a rant. (But feel free to do you, and be offended anyway).
So, my experience so far with the trans community, after
writing a few pieces that roughly touched on gender, has generally been one of “die
het cis whitie, die”. (With a few and
dear exceptions, Quinn and Michaela.)
Granted, I write stuff that can be considered…cringe-y. Inflammatory. Blunt.
Now if you’ve met me you know – I come off very gentle
and polite in person. (Okay, maybe a
little intimidating – I’m six five and too big to be subtle and graceful - what
do you want? I raise my voice half an octave at events to make you people feel less intimidated - do you have any idea how sore my throat is by the end of the night?)
Those nice manners come from being a southern gentleman
(long live Virginia, and long may the Chickahominy river flow). They come from being a law enforcement
officer. And they come from a recently
found sense of peace.
My writings on the other hand…this one? This one is going to be a little tart. And a little sappy. And….well.
You’ll see.
So.
“Cis het scum,you need to fucking die!”. “Hettie fucker”. “White cis het cunt bitch”. “Cissie fuck”. “Privileged cis asshole”. “Fascist het hate monger”. And on, and on, and on…(although cleaned up
for grammar and spelling. Jesus…did any
of you graduate grammar school?) (Part
2: Does anyone say that anymore, or am I
just old? Grammar school? Primary school? No?)
This is the kind of crap that I generally get in my mail
box, to my face at events, through my blog and through messages on Fetlife.
Apparently I’m hated by some vocal types in the trans community. I’m “regressionist”, and “transphobic”. I’m a “white hettie dinosaur entrenched in
privilege”. I should “get cancer and
die, scum cissie”. I haven't risen to the level of an actual household hate name, but I might get there.
Well, you know, when you send enough of this shit – yep,
I’m gonna start taking it personally. (Although
honestly, the biggest insult is the “white” part – I’m red, jackasses. Seriously.
I’m gonna post an image of myself next to a loaf of wonder bread for
comparison and see if you get it.)
So yeah. I got
pissy about the trans community. No
excuses.
It wasn’t until I met this person on Fetlife (Quinn) that
I saw another side to the trans and queer community. If you know her, she’s in Philly, and she’s
just such a bundle of energy and open-ness about herself and her journey that
you can’t help liking her. Gimme a tattoo
gun and I’ll tattoo “Queer Ambassador” on her forehead. (If she’ll hold still long enough. I’m pretty sure I can wrestle her down.)
And then I found out my favorite blogger on Youtube
(Blaire White) was trans – and I had to accept that there was another side to
the trans community – a side that didn’t start every conversation with “die, cissie”.
So I’m going to be a man here and own up – I owe an
apology to the trans community at large.
(The community, note, not certain individuals.)
I had an image of
you tainted by a lack of understanding, and by the drivel fired at me from my
desktop. An image that was unfair.
Now fairness doesn’t generally exist outside of a
dictionary. But I try to live somewhere
near its borders.
If you’ve never seen the v-blogger Blaire White, try her
Youtube channel. I’ve watched it for a
long time, being mostly seated in the right section of the USA airplane we’re all
crashing in
(with occasional visits on the left). I found this girl’s channel randomly one day
started watching her blogs. The
production values aren’t great – I’ve honestly considered donating some mid-grade
videography lights to her at least once.
But she’s mindful, intelligent, a bit sarcastic, and…okay, I’ll admit it
– she’s fucking hot. (Hey, I’m a male
het dinosaur, remember?)
Then one video she started talking more in depth about
herself and about the trans community, and did it from a position where I could
see that the “die cis hettie” crap wasn’t everyone. When she said straight out she was trans,(somehow
I missed that before) - I had a “moment”.
Like when you reset a Nintendo – everything just
froze for a sec and then went blank screen.
I mean look, I identify as straight (occasionally misogynist) hetero,
but I mean Christ… this girl is seriously the hottest thing you’d ever want to
spank. Her being trans, pleasantly
elocute, and intelligently moderate – even a little right leaning – I had to
rethink a lot of things I had internalized about the trans community.
(That didn’t come out right – the hotness wasn’t the “re-think”
reason – it was the “reset” reason. The
intelligence and open-ness about her transition was the re-think reason.)
So I spent a few days re-evaluating. I had to rethink a lot of the assumptions I'd made about trans men and women that I didn't even realize I'd been harboring. Rethinking the blind spots in my “live and
let live” philosophy. Reconsidering the
“judge a book by its font” philosophy. This woman, trans or not, was intelligent, entertaining, charming, and didn't fit a single one of the pigeon holes I'd built from the various hate emails I'd been receiving.
I
decided that I owed an apology.
I did what I was so pissed at the community for, and painted
you all with the brush of a single group.
I didn’t take the time to get involved in your lives and events and meet
people in order to find the non-“die, white cis scum!” folks in your
community.
I'm still going to call it like I see it. I'm still going to talk about gender - and some of you are still going to be pissed about it. I'm still going to beat on male apologists, and speak openly about MRA issues, BDSM scene issues, and where they meet.
But for my own thinking - for the pigeon holes I'd made instead of looking at individuals:
I’m sorry.
No excuses.
Comments
Post a Comment
Thank you for your comment! It will be moderated and, if not SPAM, will be posted within the next 12 hours (sooner if possible - sorry, I do work a vanilla job). Yes, that includes disagreeing ones - I welcome disagreements as much as anything.